The Human View Blog

mitochondria

Bing, ChatGPT & Claude wrote this post

January 05, 202513 min read

As AI continues to reshape how we work, think, and write, I thought I'd just post a verbatim "creative AI prompt and response flow" that yielded the below, unedited, results. The above image was generated by ChatGPT based on "create a suitable image for the post." All the other graphics are from Dreamstime.com based on my searches there for images that would be textually relevant.

Original Bing prompt
Me: What would be a good metaphorical depiction of mitochondrial dynamics as reflective of whole-body dynamics in the context of physical health and spiritual development?

mitochondria word cloud

Bing reply
Imagine mitochondria as the tiny power plants within each cell, tirelessly generating energy to keep the body functioning. Now, picture these power plants as individual musicians in a grand orchestra. Each musician (mitochondrion) plays their instrument (produces energy) in harmony with the others, creating a beautiful symphony (overall health).

In this metaphor, the conductor represents the mind and spirit, guiding the musicians to play in sync. When the conductor is in tune with the orchestra, the music flows seamlessly, reflecting a state of physical health and spiritual balance. However, if the conductor is distracted or out of sync, the music becomes chaotic, mirroring a state of imbalance or illness.

conductor

Just as a well-conducted orchestra can produce a powerful and moving performance, a body with well-functioning mitochondria can achieve optimal health and vitality. Similarly, spiritual development can be seen as the process of refining the conductor's skills, leading to a more harmonious and fulfilling life.

This metaphor highlights the interconnectedness of physical health and spiritual development, emphasizing the importance of nurturing both to achieve overall well-being.

Prompt from the above, to ChatGPT
Me: How would you evaluate Bing's response, and please generate your own response to the initial question, as well as contrasting and enhancing your perspectives.

GPT's initial reply
Bing’s metaphor is compelling, using the orchestra analogy to illustrate how mitochondrial dynamics relate to whole-body health and spiritual development. It successfully conveys the idea of harmony and interconnection. However, it could be enhanced by deepening the connection between the microscopic (mitochondria) and the macroscopic (whole-body health and spiritual growth) to show how shifts at one level reverberate across others.

GPT's "rewrite"
Imagine mitochondria as tiny campfires scattered across a vast wilderness, each burning to provide energy and warmth. Together, these fires sustain the community (the body), allowing it to thrive. When the fires are well-tended, the wilderness is alive with activity—animals move, plants grow, and the ecosystem flourishes.

wilderness

Now, envision the caretaker of the wilderness as your spirit and consciousness, observing and influencing the rhythm of these fires. The caretaker doesn’t just stoke flames—it ensures the environment supports the fires, managing air (oxygen), fuel (nutrients), and balance (stress or harmony). A balanced caretaker recognizes that over-stoking a fire leads to burnout (oxidative stress), while neglect causes dimming (fatigue or illness).

On a whole-body scale, mitochondrial health reflects this dance: dynamic adjustments between energy generation, repair, and resilience. Similarly, spiritual growth mirrors this process, requiring both active effort (reflection, discipline) and rest (letting go, mindfulness). Together, the body’s physical vitality and the spirit’s awareness create a self-sustaining cycle, where energy flows seamlessly through all levels of existence.

GPT's notes on Contrast and Enhancements:

Contrast:

Bing emphasizes harmony as directed by an external conductor, focusing on synchronization.

My metaphor highlights self-regulation and adaptability, showing how the micro (mitochondria) feeds back into the macro (spiritual growth), with interdependence rather than hierarchical control.

mitochondrial

Enhancements:

Ecological Depth: By comparing mitochondria to campfires, the analogy emphasizes the balance of resource consumption, waste management, and environmental stewardship, which parallels physical and spiritual health.

Interactive Balance: My metaphor integrates the dynamic interplay between the mitochondria and the environment (body), underlining mutual influence rather than one-way guidance.

Individuality within Unity: While Bing’s orchestra analogy suggests unity under a singular directive, the wilderness metaphor celebrates diversity, self-regulation, and adaptation within the system.

My prompt back to ChatGPT
Me: Okay, now please write a 750-word blog post that combines all of the above inputs and concepts.
 The context for the post is to present an exhortative, provocative thesis for the consideration of employers (HR & benefits) and benefit consultants, as well as benefit vendors servicing employers - all of whom are grappling with exorbitant health plan costs because of our dysfunctional healthcare and financing systems.

faulkner

Use an expert tone, with tinges of satire and sarcasm, in a somewhat William Faulkner-esque style. Present it as a positive encouragement to adopt novel and more human-centric postures in terms of employee engagement, activation, and marketing.

But weave in a few thoughts of how we've been lazily "missing the mark" by not having adopted this kind of approach sooner. The piece should evoke an emotional desire in the reader to adopt far more personalized and psychographically-informed communications, education, and call-to-action strategies.

ChatGPT's "new blog post"

Orchestrating the Symphony of Health: Why We’ve Been Missing the Mark on Employee Well-Being

Ladies and gentlemen of the HR, benefits, and vendor world—let us gather ‘round the flickering light of reason and confront a truth we’ve long danced around like moths at dusk. For all our earnest talk of innovation, engagement, and cost control, we remain stewards of a healthcare system that more closely resembles a rusted-out carnival ride than a finely tuned orchestra. And it’s costing us dearly—not just in dollars, but in the squandered potential of the very people we claim to serve.

powerhouse

Consider, for a moment, the mitochondrion: a humble powerhouse, smaller than the period at the end of this sentence, yet vital to the grand composition of human health. Each mitochondrion hums with energy, adapting, responding, creating.

Now zoom out. Picture those mitochondria as individual musicians, each contributing their part to the symphony of life within every employee’s body. When they’re in harmony, the music of vitality flows. When they falter, the dissonance reverberates through the entire system, from physical illness to spiritual malaise.

Sound familiar? It should. Our healthcare and benefits systems have long played the part of the distracted conductor—waving the baton at random, assuming the musicians will figure it out. We’ve thrown together a cacophony of plan designs, wellness programs, and communication campaigns with the grace of a middle school orchestra’s first recital. And yet we wonder why employees—those delicate ecosystems of body, mind, and spirit—are burning out, tuning out, and opting out.

The Missed Opportunities

fitbit

Let’s admit it: we’ve been lazy. For decades, we’ve relied on tired tropes, surface-level engagement strategies, and generic communications that treat employees like numbers on a ledger rather than unique humans with dreams, fears, and motivations. We’ve mailed out uninspiring enrollment brochures and crossed our fingers that someone, somewhere, might actually read them. We’ve built wellness programs like mousetraps, hoping a free Fitbit would coax employees into a labyrinth of activity tracking, surveys, and competitions they didn’t ask for.

And yet, the costs keep rising. Chronic diseases march on. Mental health crises multiply. Absenteeism, presenteeism, and disengagement sap the workforce. All the while, our collective response has been to tweak the same tired levers: higher deductibles, narrower networks, and the occasional “employee wellness day” that looks good on LinkedIn but leaves the orchestra as out of tune as ever.

The Wilderness Within

To escape this vicious cycle, we need a new metaphor—one that goes beyond the conductor and the orchestra. Imagine the employee as a wilderness: a vibrant, interconnected ecosystem sustained by countless tiny fires (those mitochondria again). These fires burn energy, generate life, and adapt to the environment. But they also require balance. Over-stoke them, and the forest burns. Neglect them, and the wilderness falls silent.

As employers and benefits professionals, we are not the keepers of this wilderness. Employees are. Our role is to equip them with the tools, knowledge, and environments that allow their ecosystems to thrive. This means stepping beyond the cookie-cutter campaigns of yore and embracing personalized, psychographically-informed strategies that resonate with the unique rhythms of each employee’s life.

The Call to Action: A More Human-Centric Approach

void within

We’ve been talking about “employee activation” as though it’s a one-size-fits-all magic trick. But what if we treated it as an art form instead? A symphony is not built on a single melody, nor does a forest thrive on one species of tree. Why, then, do we persist in sending identical messages to employees whose motivations, fears, and aspirations couldn’t be more different?

Imagine communications as finely tuned as a bespoke suit, crafted to fit the psychographic profiles of the people they’re meant to inspire. To the data-driven employee, we present numbers: the cost savings of preventative care. To the wellness enthusiast, we highlight holistic resources. To the skeptical cynic, we offer straightforward truths without the usual marketing fluff. Each message tailored, each call to action resonant.

And let us not stop at words. Let our platforms, tools, and programs speak the language of human lives. Let them inspire not compliance but connection. Instead of enrolling in benefits because they have to, employees should feel drawn to engage because they see themselves—their needs, their families, their futures—reflected in what we offer.

A Final Note: Satire and Salvation

Is it not a little absurd that we’re having this conversation in 2025? That we’re just now awakening to the idea that employees are humans with complex inner lives? That we’ve spent decades building systems to manage costs without truly addressing the health, resilience, and humanity of those who bear them?

But here’s the beauty of it: we have the tools. We have the data, the technology, and the creativity to make this shift. All that’s required is the will to step away from the old playbook and embrace something richer, more dynamic, and undeniably human.

stoke the fires

So, HR leaders, benefit consultants, and vendors: the time has come to stoke the fires, tune the instruments, and rewrite the score. Let us build ecosystems of health that resonate not just in spreadsheets but in the lives of the people we serve. Let us be the caretakers of a new symphony—one of vitality, connection, and meaning.

Because the wilderness is waiting. And it’s time we learned to tend the flames.

<END CHATGPT BLOG POST CREATION>

---------------

Next, I took the entire ChatGPT Blog Post, and fed it into Claude Opus, using this prompt:

Me: Please rewrite this in your own voice, retaining the basic metaphorical framework, but adding whatever flourishes seem to you to enhance the effectiveness and persuasiveness of the piece. Keep the length, but feel free to play with the tone and flow of the input.

Here is Claude Opus' rewrite:

The Symphony of Employee Well-Being: A New Score for HR

conductor

Esteemed colleagues in the realm of human resources, benefits, and workforce management, the time has come for us to face an uncomfortable truth. Despite our best intentions and countless initiatives, we find ourselves conducting an orchestra of employee well-being that is painfully out of tune. The healthcare system we have long presided over more closely resembles a discordant cacophony than a harmonious symphony, and the price we pay is not just measured in dollars, but in the untapped potential of our most valuable asset—our people.

To understand the root of this dissonance, let us consider the mitochondrion, the tiny yet mighty powerhouse that fuels the very essence of human vitality. Just as each mitochondrion plays a crucial role in the grand composition of an individual's health, so too does each employee contribute to the overall well-being of our organizations. When these cellular musicians are in sync, the melody of productivity and engagement flows effortlessly. However, when they falter, the ripple effect of disharmony can be felt throughout the entire company, manifesting as absenteeism, burnout, and a general sense of malaise.

The Conductor's Missteps

one size fits all

As stewards of employee well-being, we must acknowledge that we have often fallen short in our role as conductors. For far too long, we have relied on generic, one-size-fits-all approaches to benefits communication and wellness initiatives, treating our employees as mere cogs in a machine rather than the unique, multifaceted individuals they are. We have bombarded them with uninspired enrollment materials, hoping against hope that they might decipher the complex language and make informed decisions. We have dangled the carrot of wellness programs, expecting that the allure of a shiny new fitness tracker would be enough to inspire lasting behavior change.

Yet, despite our efforts, healthcare costs continue to soar, chronic diseases persist, and mental health challenges multiply. The workforce remains disengaged, and our attempts to rectify the situation have been akin to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. We tinker with plan designs, adjust deductibles, and offer the occasional token gesture of employee appreciation, all while the underlying melody of well-being remains woefully out of tune.

The Employee Ecosystem

To break free from this cycle of dissonance, we must embrace a new paradigm—one that recognizes each employee as a complex, interconnected ecosystem. Like a thriving forest, their well-being is sustained by countless tiny fires, those mitochondrial sparks that fuel their physical, mental, and emotional vitality. Our role, then, is not to dictate the rhythm of these fires, but rather to cultivate an environment in which they can flourish.

employee eocsystem

This shift demands that we move beyond the tired tropes and generic strategies of yesteryear and instead embrace a more personalized, empathetic approach to employee engagement. We must craft communications that resonate with the unique psychographic profiles of our diverse workforce, speaking to their individual motivations, fears, and aspirations. To the data-driven skeptic, we present the hard facts about the value of preventive care. To the wellness enthusiast, we highlight the holistic resources available to nurture their mind, body, and spirit. And to the disengaged cynic, we offer authentic, no-nonsense guidance that cuts through the usual corporate jargon.

The Harmony of Humanity

As we strive to create a more human-centric approach to employee well-being, let us not forget the absurdity of the fact that we are having this conversation in the year 2025. For decades, we have been building systems and processes designed to manage costs, while neglecting the very essence of what makes our organizations thrive—the health, resilience, and humanity of our people.

human harmony

But herein lies the opportunity. We possess the knowledge, the technology, and the ingenuity to orchestrate a new symphony of well-being. By embracing the inherent complexity and diversity of our workforce, we can create benefits ecosystems that resonate not just in the realm of ROI, but in the lives of those we serve.

So, my fellow conductors of the HR world, let us raise our batons and set a new tempo. Let us stoke the fires of vitality, tune the instruments of engagement, and compose a score that celebrates the unique melody within each employee. Together, we can cultivate a thriving workplace ecosystem—one that not only optimizes costs but also unlocks the boundless potential of our most precious resource: our people.

The stage is set, the orchestra awaits. Let the symphony of well-being begin.

<END CLAUDE OPUS BLOG POST CREATION>

--------------------

Again, all of these prompts and responses are completely verbatim and unedited.

I found going through this process fascinating, and I hope you found reading it equally so.

~ Mark Head
© 2025. All Rights Reserved.

Logo

Click the green button or the blue button (below) to visit our scheduling pages.

Want a deep driver15 min30 min

Back to Blog

Mark Head

President

With 4 decades of combined experience in employee benefits consulting, wellness and health management, Head brings a unique combination of dynamic perspectives into a clear vision of where the future of health care is moving - and it's moving towards deeper human connection, awareness, and engagement...

Contact Information

mark.head@benefitpersonas.com

(214) 455-3706

Follow Us On

© 2015 - 2024, MDH Consulting. All Rights Reserved.